Goblin Episode 8: Ending Monologue

Theory on Shin’s ending monologue/diary entry:

Shin’s internal monologue is his last wish. He knows that he has to let Eun Tak pull out the sword so that she can survive and he’s accepting that here. What he’s doing is making the wish that he and Eun Tak are reborn together so that he can love her again [and confess to her then that she is his first love].

One day after 100 years

When the weather is good enough

I wish I could tell her

that she was my first love

This is Shin accepting his death as inevitable. In order to save ET from all these accidents that are happening, and let her live a long, happy life, he needs to let her pull out the sword.

To spend a lifetime with Eun Tak, Shin was hoping earlier in the episode to spend 80 more years alive as a Goblin [a rough estimate of the years left in Eun Tak's lifetime. Even if it means dealing with constant pain from the sword, that's what he wants; a lifetime with her. But here's the problem....

ET’s birthmark is fading; she’s losing her purpose in life because Shin isn’t letting her pull out the sword. There’s a time limit to how long Shin can keep prolonging the sword being removed.
Once the birthmark fades, time is up.

Eun Tak is 19 years old right now. The average human lifespan is ~100 years, give or take a few. If we factor in that there may be a waiting period between the time of death and time of rebirth, 100 years would also be a rough estimate of the time Eun Tak herself would be reborn in her next life. So what Shin is asking is to be reborn with her. He wants to meet her again in his next life and he wants her to be his first love again in his next life. He wants to be able to tell her what he thinks he cannot/should not tell her now; She is his first love.

Shin accepting his death here also parallels the way the Queen had to accept her death in Joseon times.

Like Shin, the Queen had to accept that she would have to die to protect someone she loves.

Like Shin, the Queen had to accept that she would die AT the hands of someone she loves.

To me, this is the true punishment; not his 900 year stint as a Goblin.

Shin needs to feel what the Queen was feeling at the time of her death. He needs to feel exactly what it’s like to not only die at the hands of someone he loves, but to resign himself to the fact that he HAS to die at the hands of someone he loves, in order to save that person. And it must be at the time when he most wants to live.

The moment the Queen was shot is what I suspect to be the moment she most wanted to live. She wanted the King to choose to save her, but instead he chose to kill her.


Thoughts on the Future Sequence:

So far we know that Shin can see into someone’s future, but we don’t know exactly how far. What if the vision he sees of Eun Tak at 29 isn’t the Eun Tak in this life, but ET in her next life?

Shin tells us that sometimes people are born with the same face. It could be that ET is born with the same face in her next life and she happens to come across the same waiter [also in his next life but not necessarily the same face]. It could be that the Deity was trying to show him that even if he has to give up his happiness with her in this life, there is still the possibility of meeting her in the next.

Our happy ending may not be a happy ending in this life, but in the next. 

Goblin: Queen Sunny vs Queen Reaper

Goblin: Who is Queen? 

Sunny 3 vs. Grim Reaper 9

Sunny:

1. She's female. Although as people pointed out, the Reaper pointed out himself gender shouldn't be presumed as static in reincarnations. 

2. The lapel pin. The Reaper wears a lapel pin on his black suit uniform.  It’s the chess symbol for the King. ♔ (I tried to insert the unicode here. Hope you can see it.) It’s possible that the costume director pinned the King’s crown on the Reaper’s suit to signal that he IS the king. It’s like ET’s name tag for the chicken store. If he’s the King then Sunny is the Queen. However, there’s a counter-argument. 

3. The ring. Sunny has an interest in and eventually wears the same jade ring as the Joseon era Queen. She even wears it on the same finger.

4. The scroll paintings. The King has a lot of painted scrolls of the Queen around his deathbed (possibly indicating his remorse for killing her)

5. Her name. Kim Sun Hee. This is the name of the Joseon Era Queen.

Grim Reaper:

1. Because Goblin/Reaper bromance sound like two siblings squabbling to me.  

2. Because the apathetic, self-centered, shallow, and weak character of the King (can you tell that I don't like him much?) resembles Sunny's character, more so than the Reaper's.  She owns a chicken shop but doesn't work it. She's easy-going as long as she isn't inconvenienced. She consults a shaman just like the King relied on the eunuch's counsel. 

3. Because of the finger gun. That was a cute gesture but it reminded me of how the king ordered the queen killed. Ominous.

4. Because of the tears. The queen was the one to shed a tear, just like the Reaper did upon seeing his ring. 

5. Because the bloodstain on the ring is hers. Just like the bloodstain on the sword is Shin's. They marked their possessions with bloodshed. 

6. Because the queen actually does have blood on her hands. Didn’t she tell Shin to go ahead and walk to the King fully aware of the wrath of the King?  I say: negligent homicide, maximum penitentiary time, no parole.... in keeping with the edict of the cabbage/fairy grandmother. I'm being cruel, though.

...7. The lapel pin. It’s also possible that the costume director pinned the King’s crown NOT to designate the identity of the king but to show the wearer’s ALLEGIANCE to the king. For instance, American politicians wear a flag pin, not because they’re flag-bearers, but to show patriotism (whether or not it’s real is debatable, however....) Military personnel wear a lapel pin to show their branch of affiliation. And the British wear a poppy on Remembrance Day to remember the veterans and those soldiers who died in WWI. So, the king's crown lapel pin will indicate that the Reaper is NOT the king. (Confusing, no?)

8. His last name is the same as Shin’s. KIM. When he signed off on the Reapers' paperwork, he wrote "Kim" according to the kdrama sub. It’s possible that this is a generic name for all reapers. But it’s also likely that it’s some sort of cosmic joke from the kdrama gods. Like a twisted “I’m really your long-lost sibling” trope. Also, when he introduced himself as Kim Woo Bin to Sunny. 

9. The frown. At 15:14 min in Episode 6, there was a montage of the memories of Shin. I heard that people were wondering why that particular image of Sunny was chosen.  The look on the King’s face as he was glaring down at Shin the warrior on bended knees was matched with Sunny’s look as she was staring down at the Reaper’s bent head. 

*These are the combined opinions of fans of the show to make it easy to find/follow. All opinions posted with express permission from/at the request of the original owner*